Problems for Buckyball, diamond and Graphite Topic

Problem Section 1.1 (basic nomenclature)

1) List the three subatomic particles and their charges.

2) List the three subatomic particles and their masses in amu.

3) What composes most of the volume of an atom?

4) What are the two particles in the nucleus of an atom?

5) What does "amu" stand for?

6) Define "isotope" in your own words, and give an example of two isotopes of the same element.

8) If a carbon atom weighs 13 amu, how many protons and neutrons does it contain?

9) How many electrons are there in the outer shell of an oxygen atom?

10 a) In your own words, write a definition for "molecule."

b) In 1990, diamond was the "molecule of the year" due to its ability to be made into thin films. Based on your definition of molecule, does this title make sense? If not, pick a more appropriate title for the award in 1990 and explain your decision.

c) In 1991, buckyballs were given the title "molecule of the year." Explain if this was an accurate title given your definition of molecule.

11) Suppose you are asked to count how many coins there are in a truck piled full of nickels. One strategy would be to count out each nickel individually. While this would work, an indirect method would be much faster. Instead, you could determine the weight of all the nickels in the truckload and divide that number by the weight of a single nickel. Of course, this supposes that all nickels weigh the exact same amount. When chemists want to determine how many atoms there are in a sample of an element they use the same indirect approach. You may find it useful to complete the following problem side by side ('a' and 'A' together, etc.).

Suppose that 90% of all nickels weigh 5.00 grams, while the remaining 10% weigh 7.00 grams due to different materials used during the minting process. To get an accurate count, you will need to consider both kinds of coins.

a) If you had 100 nickels, about how many of them would weigh 5.00 grams?

b) If you had 100 nickels, about how many of them would weigh 7.00 grams?

c) How much would these 100 nickels weigh?

d) How much do these nickels weigh on average?

This average weight in nickels is an "effective weight" for a single nickel.

e) If the weight of the nickels on the truck was 41,600 grams, how many nickels were on the truck?

In nature, the element copper occurs in two different isotopes. 70% of copper atoms weigh 63 amu, while the remaining 30% weigh 65 amu. If you wanted to indirectly count the number of Cu atoms in a large sample of Cu, you would need to take both isotopes into consideration.

A) If you had 100 Cu atoms, about how many of them would weigh 63 amu?

B) If you had 100 Cu atoms, about how many of them would weigh 65 amu?

C) How much would these 100 Cu atoms weigh?

D) How much do these atoms weigh on average?

Again, this is an "effective weight" for Cu atoms - and is the number listed on the periodic table for it's atomic mass. Check and see if your number agrees with the periodic table.

E) If you had 636,000 amu of copper, how many copper atoms would you have?

Imagine a bank where all transactions concerning nickels used this kind of weighing scheme alone (so, the face value of the coin is no longer important, just it's weight). If you were to bring in only two nickels, obviously 90% of them couldn't be 5.00 gram nickels, and 10% be 7.00 gram nickels. Most of the time, the two nickels would both be the 5.00 gram variety. How would this effect you? The weight of your two coins would probably be less than the weight of nickels on average - so, you would be getting less than your ten cents worth! This is a classic sampling size problem - the number of nickels you are looking at is too small to use average percents accurately.

f) Do chemists need to worry about the same kind of sampling size problems when they weigh out substances and use the atomic mass from the periodic table?

Problem Section 1.2 (Bucky questions, spectroscopy questions)

1) Why do buckyballs show one 13C NMR signal? When C60 was discovered, a small amount of a similar compound, C70 was also found. The C70 looks similar to the C60 molecule, except it is elongated into a football shape. Explain whether you would predict one 13C signal for C70?

2) Bromine has two isotopes which are roughly equally abundant. Briefly describe what you would see in a mass spectrum of bromine atoms.

3) Write the number of 13C NMR signals that would result from each of the following structures. Place letters next to each atom to label which are equivalent. So, if you thought that two carbons were equivalent, you would place the same letter next to each one - if an atom is unique, it would have its own letter.

Using the bonding rules you have learned for carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen, write out structures for the following molecules (like the two above), and predict the number of 13C NMR signals and 1H NMR signals that would be found for each. (hint: the formula given below for ethanol is given in "condensed form" which is meant to suggest how the atoms are connected)

Ethane: C2H6 Ethanol: CH3CH2OH

4) Label the different carbon environments that 13C NMR would see in the following molecules. The first is done as an example.

5) In 1985 Kroto and Smalley suggested a possible structure of Buckyball based on their mass spectrum data. However, the general scientific community did not consider it proven until the 13C NMR was published. Write a short essay on why the structure was not considered proven until the NMR spectrum was obtained and how the NMR data proved the structure.

6) a) Shown below is the mass spectrum of propane, C3H8.

Sketch a mass spectrum for each of the following (be sure to include labeled axis as seen in example):

b) The 13C NMR spectrum for propane is shown below. Sketch the 13C NMR spectrum of propene and of cyclopropane.

7) Imagine that you are asked to identify an unknown compound. The compound contains only carbon and hydrogen. The mass spectrum of the compound shows a large peak at 52 amu. The 13C NMR shows one peak. Construct a structure that is consistent with these observations and with the bonding rules of carbon. Discuss why your molecule fits the observed data.

8) To the right is shown the mass spectrum of methane, CH4. The major peak is at 16 amu. There is another peak in the spectrum that is approximately one hundredth of the size of the main peak and comes at 17 amu. Explain the presence of this small peak. Keep in mind that this is a pure sample, i.e. it is all CH4.

9) A hot news item from one year ago concerned the noxious gases that appear to have been released from a dead woman's body in a Riverside, California hospital. Imagine that you are part of the task force that is charged with determining the nature of the emitted gas. Suppose that from air samples you are able to isolate a gas that exhibits the following properties.

Mass Spectrum:One peak at 34 amu
13C NMR:No peaks
1H NMR:One peak
15N NMR:No peaks
31P NMR:One peak
a) What is the noxious gas?

b) Why does it have a peak in the mass spectrum at 34 amu?

c) Why are there no peaks in the 13C NMR spectrum?

d) Why is there one peak in the 1H NMR spectrum?

e) Why are there no peaks in the 15N NMR spectrum?

f) Why is there one peak in the 31P NMR spectrum?

Problem Section 2.1 Carbon Fibers and Graphite

1) a) If a carbon fiber is heated to a hot enough temperature it can be turned into a graphite fiber. Carbon fibers are a very strong material that is used in a wide variety of applications. Graphite fibers are not used industrially. Rationalize this based upon what you know about their structures.

b) A controversy has arisen over the name "graphite fiber" being associated with sporting goods equipment. You are the aide to a senator who is giving a press conference on the subject. Write a one paragraph essay giving the senator's position on the issue.

Problem Section 2.2 Diamonds

1) a) Consider the two energy diagrams, a and b, shown below. Put appropriate labels on the x and y axis.

b) If you were to try to push a car from the left to the right on each curve, which would occur more readily?

c) Which would you get more energy out of from start to finish?

d) Draw an energy diagram that shows the relative stability of diamond and graphite.

e) Why doesn't diamond convert to graphite?

2) An article appears in the your local newspaper with the following headline: "Professor at UW discovers that Diamonds Are Unstable". The article goes on to suggest that diamonds are poor investments because they will eventually turn into graphite. Write a letter to the editor that challenges this statement. Your letter must use the terms thermodynamics and kinetics, but it must explain how they apply to the article in a language that your roomate, for example, could understand.

3) This question concerns the burning of diamonds and graphite to produce carbon dioxide.

a) Write balanced equations for each reaction.

b) If you burn 12 g of diamonds, how many grams of CO2 will be produced?

c) Now burn 12 g of graphite. How many grams of CO2 are produced in this instance?

d) Two incomplete reaction coordinate diagrams (aka energy profiles) that describe the burning of diamonds are shown below. First locate and mark the portion of the curve corresponding to CO2. Next clearly mark which curve describes the burning of diamonds and which curve describes the burning of graphite. Explain your decision.

e) Diamonds and graphite need a flame or spark to start burning in the presence of O2. Use the energy profiles to rationalize why we need a spark or flame to start a fire.